Choosing between the Casper One and the Casper Original comes down to personal sleep preferences — both mattresses deliver high-quality comfort to align with your firmness and support needs.
Casper has been transforming the way people sleep since its inception, blending innovative design with comfort and support that suits every sleeper.
With high-quality materials and a commitment to creating unmatched sleep experiences, Casper continues to push the boundaries of comfort and durability, offering options that fit a wide range of sleep styles and preferences.
With the arrival of the Casper One affordable foam mattress, you might be wondering how it compares to the tried-and-true Original. In this guide, we’re breaking down the key differences between the Casper One vs Original, including their construction, feel, and overall sleep experience, so you can find the perfect fit for your unique needs.
Casper One vs Original Comparison Chart
|
Category |
Casper One |
Casper Original |
|
Construction & Materials |
All-foam construction for a firmer, more uniform surface. Designed to distribute weight evenly, prioritizing support across the entire mattress. |
Three layers of premium foam, with zoned support that varies in density to provide extra reinforcement where you need it most (hips), and softer comfort under the shoulders. |
|
Firmness & Comfort |
Medium-firm feel. Slightly firmer top layer keeps back and stomach sleepers comfortably elevated throughout the night. |
Balanced medium feel. Zoned foam accommodates a range of positions, making it ideal for combination sleepers seeking pressure relief and spinal alignment. |
|
Cooling & Breathability |
Advanced foam technology disperses body heat efficiently, making it a top choice for hot sleepers or those in warm climates. |
Open-cell foam with perforations to promote airflow for moderate climates. Offers a comfortable sleep environment without excessive heat retention. |
|
Edge Support & Durability |
Reinforced perimeter foam for strong edge support, making it suitable for people who sit or rest near the bed’s sides. Denser foam construction can contribute to extended durability. |
Sturdy base foam ensures consistent support across the entire mattress. Provides reliable performance over time, especially for those who tend to sleep more toward the center. |
|
Pricing & Value |
Priced slightly higher in some sizes but features denser foam for a potentially longer-lasting investment. |
Generally comes at a lower price point while still delivering quality comfort and support, making it a budget-friendly option. |
|
Who Should Choose It |
- Ideal for stomach sleepers who need a firmer feel - Anyone valuing stronger edge support and long-lasting foam - Hot sleepers seeking advanced cooling features |
- Best for combination sleepers who need adaptability across multiple positions - Those who prefer a balanced comfort level for all sleeping styles - Sleepers under ~200 lbs |
Let’s take a closer look at each category below.
Construction & Materials
The construction and materials of your mattress play a huge role in its comfort and support. Discover how these design differences can help you find your ideal match1:
- Casper One – Designed for those who prefer a firmer, more uniform surface, the One features an all-foam construction that prioritizes even support across the mattress.
- Casper Original – Built with three layers of premium foam, the Original features targeted zones of varying density to provide extra support where you need it most.
How do these differences translate to firmness and comfort?
Firmness & Comfort
Some sleepers love a little plushness, while others prefer a firmer surface that keeps them lifted — Casper ensures an option for every preference. Let’s take a closer look:
- Casper One – Designed for those who like a sturdier surface, the One has a medium-firm feel that offers an even, reliable lift. With a slightly firmer top layer, it keeps back and stomach sleepers comfortably elevated throughout the night.
- Casper Original – A balanced medium feel makes the Original a go-to for combination sleepers. Its zoned foam construction provides softer support under the shoulders and firmer reinforcement under the hips, promoting spinal alignment without sacrificing comfort.
Learn more about medium vs firm mattresses in our blog. Of course, how a mattress feels is only part of the equation — temperature regulation is just as important.
Next, we’ll look at how each model helps you stay cool at night.
Cooling & Breathability
When it comes to temperature regulation, each design takes a different approach:
- Casper One – Featuring advanced foam technology that efficiently disperses body heat, the Casper One is a top choice for hot sleepers or those in warmer climates.
- Casper Original – Designed with open-cell foam and perforations, the Casper Original promotes airflow to maintain a comfortable sleep environment. Ideal for sleepers in moderate climates, it offers a balance of comfort and breathability.
Edge Support & Durability
Whether you tend to push the limits of your sleep surface, or just want extra resilience over time, here’s how each Casper mattress holds up:
- Casper One – With reinforced perimeter foam, the Casper One ensures optimal edge support, perfect for sleepers who enjoy sitting or resting along the mattress sides.
- Casper Original – Crafted with a reliable base foam, the Casper Original provides consistent support across the mattress, ideal for those who sleep more toward the center.
Pricing & Value
Both the Casper Original and the Casper One offer great value, but the balance of features and cost could be the deciding factor for you:
- Casper One – While priced slightly higher in some mattress sizes, the Casper One features denser foam and may provide a longer-lasting investment for those looking for the ultimate in durability.
- Casper Original – The Original delivers solid comfort and support at an approachable price point, making it an excellent option for budget-conscious shoppers.
Who Should Choose Which?
The choice between the Casper One vs Original isn’t one-size-fits-all. Each model has its unique strengths, so finding the right match means aligning your needs with the features that matter most.
Not sure where to start? Don’t worry — that’s what we’re here for.
Choose the Casper Original If…
You want a mattress that offers universal comfort and versatility for a wide range of sleeping styles.
The Casper Original is ideal for:
- Combination sleepers who need a mattress that adapts as they move
- Those seeking a balanced comfort level that suits all sleeping positions
- Sleepers under 200 lbs who want enough pressure relief to feel cozy without sinking2
Choose the Casper One If…
You’re looking for a more tailored, supportive sleep surface that caters to your body’s specific needs.
The Casper One is the perfect upgrade for:
- Stomach sleepers who crave a firmer, more supportive feel
- Those who value stronger edge support and long-lasting foam
- The latest in cooling tech and durable design
Whichever sleep experience you choose, rest easy knowing that Casper combines innovation with comfort for rejuvenation you can feel.
Experience the Casper Difference Today
At Casper, every mattress is crafted with a deep understanding of what truly creates a restful night’s sleep.
Whether you’re after the firmer, more supportive feel of the Casper One or the well-rounded, balanced comfort of the Original, both options promise signature quality and innovation.
Take the first step toward better sleep today by visiting Casper and upgrading your mattress experience.
Sources:
- Sleep Foundation. Mattress Construction. https://www.sleepfoundation.org/mattress-construction
- Sleep Foundation. Body Weight. https://www.sleepfoundation.org/research-methodology/body-weight
- Science Direct. Quantitative effects of mattress types (comfortable vs. uncomfortable) on sleep quality through polysomnography and skin temperature. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0169814106001508
